/claim #18

Summary

• Adds a self-contained scientific-bounty-review-integrity module for the review and payout-readiness layer of the Scientific Bounty System.
• Builds deterministic evidence manifests with SHA-256 hashes for submitted artifacts.
• Excludes conflicted reviewers before scoring and evaluates weighted rubrics against a passing threshold.
• Produces milestone-level payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and an audit hash for sponsor review.

Demo

• Visual demo artifact: scientific-bounty-review-integrity/docs/demo.svg
• CLI demo: node scientific-bounty-review-integrity/demo.js
• The demo uses synthetic sample data only and requires no credentials, live research data, or external services.

Validation

• node scientific-bounty-review-integrity/test.js -> passed
• node scientific-bounty-review-integrity/demo.js -> produced reviewer-ready JSON decision record
• git diff --check -> passed

Notes

• Dependency-free Node.js implementation using only built-in modules.
• No credentials, live data, external APIs, or package installation required.

Current status - 2026-05-30 00:31 IST

Verified after newer same-issue #18 activity: this PR remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-table listed, and claim-marked for issue #18.

This PR covers the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness decision layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone-level payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #423 covers challenge prequalification fairness before solver acceptance/rejection: published criteria, reviewer score evidence, appeal windows, anonymous screening requirements, reviewer quorum/deduplication, and applicant hold/remediation states. That is adjacent Scientific Bounty System work, but it does not replace PR #108’s review-integrity and payout-readiness layer.

No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.

Current status - 2026-05-30 01:30 IST

Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #18 PR #423 later than my last PR-body status. PR #108 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-table listed, and claim-marked for issue #18.

PR #108 remains the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #423 remains a separate challenge-prequalification fairness guard for criteria publication, reviewer score evidence, appeal windows, anonymous screening requirements, reviewer quorum/deduplication, and applicant remediation states. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.

Current status - 2026-05-30 02:13 IST

Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #18 PR #423 again. PR #108 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-table listed, and claim-marked for issue #18.

PR #108 remains the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #423 remains a separate challenge-prequalification fairness guard. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.

Current status - 2026-05-30 02:45 IST

Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #18 PR #423 later than my last status. PR #108 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-table listed, and claim-marked for issue #18.

PR #108 remains the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #423 remains a separate challenge-prequalification fairness guard. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.

Current status - 2026-05-30 11:45 IST

Visibility refresh after KoiosSG updated same-issue #18 PR #423 later than my last PR-body status. PR #108 remains open, non-draft, MERGEABLE, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #18. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 1,000: https://algora.io/claims/QWhzCXU5Bxj795Mv

PR #108 remains the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #423 remains a separate challenge-prequalification fairness guard. No contributor-side code changes are pending unless maintainers request revisions.

Current status - 2026-06-02 21:25 IST

Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #18 activity from @Jorel97 / PR #562. PR #108 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #18. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 1,000: https://algora.io/claims/QWhzCXU5Bxj795Mv

PR #108 remains the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #562 is a separate sponsor escrow readiness guard for escrow evidence, underfunding, stale or expiring funding proof, unsupported currencies, payout schedule reconciliation, and missing release authorization. No contributor-side code changes are pending for PR #108 unless maintainers request revisions.

Current status - 2026-06-03 12:02 UTC

Visibility refresh after newer same-issue #18 activity on @KoiosSG PR #423. PR #108 remains open, non-draft, CLEAN/mergeable, bounty-labeled, and claim-marked for issue #18. Its Algora claim remains Pending for USD 1,000: https://algora.io/claims/QWhzCXU5Bxj795Mv

PR #108 remains the scientific-bounty review-integrity and payout-readiness layer: deterministic evidence manifests, SHA-256 artifact hashes, conflicted-reviewer exclusion before scoring, weighted rubric threshold evaluation, milestone payout splits, IP handoff state, blocker reasons, and sponsor/reviewer audit records.

PR #423 is a separate challenge-prequalification fairness guard for sponsor-side prequalification packets before solver acceptance or rejection. No contributor-side code changes are pending for PR #108 unless maintainers request revisions.